The Myth of Local Control

One common argument against statewide zoning reform is that local control of zoning is a venerable democratic norm. But in fact, state government often controls local land use in a variety of ways.

3 minute read

April 16, 2023, 5:00 AM PDT

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn


New York City Zoning Map

New York City Planning Commission / New York City Zoning Map

In recent years, some state governments have sought to reform local zoning by limiting localities' ability to exclude new housing. One of the most common arguments against such reform is that local control of zoning is so well-established as to be a democratic norm. For example, Aaron Renn writes that banning single-family zoning involves a “shift from local to state control... [that] would completely upend this country's traditional approach to land use.” (1)

But in fact, state government already interferes with local control in a variety of ways, especially in regulation-addicted states like New York. For example:

*The state caps floor-area ratio at 12. This means that a landowner cannot build anything with over twelve stories, unless it a) allows some floor area to go unused or b) purchases development rights from other landowners or otherwise takes advantage of arcane zoning loopholes. This law seems to be limited to New York City. Because car pollution is reduced when people are allowed to build housing and offices in places which (like New York City) have lots of public transit, this law seems to be environmentally harmful. (2) 

*The state has an environmental review statute which ensures that large-scale construction can be delayed by environmental impact statements. Since state courts have the right to require supplemental environmental impact statements, this means that development opponents can (in theory) delay building by claiming that every environmental statement failed to consider something. Although this law is not limited to New York City, as a practical matter it targets infill development. Why? Because development at the edge of suburbia may not have as many neighbors as infill development, which means there are fewer people who are tempted to use state law to slow down such development.

*Rent control is governed by state law.

In addition, issues related to automobile traffic are often governed by state law. For example, the city had to get state permission to implement congestion pricing in Manhattan, and to slow down traffic with speed cameras.

Admittedly, some of the abovementioned laws are roughly similar to what some local governments would do without state interference: for example, New York City has its own floor-area requirements. But state law deprives cities of the flexibility that they can use to tweak or reform those laws.

So in New York, local control seems to be a widely accepted norm only as to regulations that limit housing supply or facilitate dangerously fast automobile traffic. But if a city's government wants to allow more housing or to protect its citizens from car pollution and traffic violence, the state is quite happy to intervene.

If New York's experience is typical, local control is our “traditional approach to land use” only when it creates suburban sprawl or makes streets more dangerous.

(1) Incidentally, this statement is questionable for a reason unrelated to this article: Renn admits that most of these reforms involve allowing landowners to substitute four-plexes for single-family homes. But since this still allows exclusion of larger apartment buildings, this seems to be to be a very modest reform—I suspect too modest to do much good.

(2) One common counterargument is that high-rises are less energy-efficient than shorter buildings. I have responded to that argument in Sec. IV_D of this article. 


Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is a professor at Touro University, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at http://works.bepress.com/lewyn.

Single-family homes in a suburban neighborhood in Florida.

New Florida Law Curbs HOA Power

The legislation seeks to cut down on ‘absurd’ citations for low-level violations.

June 16, 2024 - The Guardian

Multistory apartment building under construction.

New Tennessee Law Allows No-Cost Incentives for Affordable Housing

Local governments in the Volunteer State can now offer developers incentives like increased density, lower parking requirements, and priority permitting for affordable housing projects.

June 10, 2024 - Nooga Today

Aerial view of intersection in New York City with yellow cabs and zebra crosswalks.

Planners’ Complicity in Excessive Traffic Deaths

Professor Wes Marshall’s provocatively-titled new book, "Killed by a Traffic Engineer," has stimulated fierce debates. Are his criticisms justified? Let’s examine the degree that traffic engineers contribute to avoidable traffic deaths.

June 13, 2024 - Todd Litman

Brick high-rise apartment buildings in New York City

Study: Housing Crisis is About Affordability, not Supply

New research shows that there is no overall shortage of housing units, but all U.S. metropolitan areas face a severe lack of affordable units for low-income renters.

June 18 - University of Kansas

Couple on one side of desk with banker on other side looking at paperwork.

Are Race-Based Lawsuits Affecting Community Lenders?

Shelterforce spoke with community lending leaders and experts about the current mood across the sector. What, if anything, are organizations doing to avoid becoming the next target of conservative activists?

June 18 - Shelterforce Magazine

Rendering of Glory Park in Lewisville, Texas.

New Park Promotes Community and Connectivity in Lewisville, Texas

The city of Lewisville just celebrated the opening of Glory Park/Parque la Gloria, helping to improve park access and the quality of life for residents.

June 18 - Lewisville Leader

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.